Critical criticism concerning the investigation into the demise of two Argentine ladies in Paraguay

The 11-year-old ladies had been shot throughout a army operation in opposition to a guerrilla group in September. For Human Rights Watch, there have been severe irregularities. And he accuses the federal government of Abdo Benítez.

In September, the demise of two Argentine ladies in a army operation in northern Paraguay brought about commotion and a diplomatic crossroads. Now the Asunción authorities are being focused by worldwide organizations for the alleged violation of human rights.

“The authorities of Paraguay destroyed crucial proof associated to the demise of two 11-year-old Argentine ladies brought on by brokers of the State safety forces and violated each their very own investigation protocols and worldwide human rights requirements, “he denounced Human Rights Watch. And he careworn that the federal government of that nation “should assure an investigation of these deaths in an impartial, neutral, clear and directly.”

On September 2, members of the Joint Job Drive, an elite unit led by the Armed Forces that features law enforcement officials and brokers of the Nationwide Anti-Drug Secretariat, allegedly killed Lilian Mariana Villalba and María Carmen Villalba throughout an operation in opposition to a camp. of the armed group Paraguayan Folks’s Military (EPP) in a wooded space some 360 ​​kilometers northeast of Asunción.

The mom of one of many ladies, who had been cousins, informed Human Rights Watch that each had been born and lived in Argentina however had been within the camp visiting his mother and father, who’re members of the armed group.

“There are severe irregularities within the investigation,” mentioned José Miguel Vivanco, director of the Americas Division of Human Rights Watch. “The Paraguayan authorities should instantly enable Argentine forensic specialists to hold out an post-mortem and that they and the victims’ households have full entry to the proof collected. The longer the federal government delays, the extra probably it’s that potential proof will disappear within the stays, “he added, in keeping with an announcement from the group.

Shortly after the operation, Paraguayan President Mario Abdo Benítez traveled to the camp, described the operation as “profitable in each manner” and mentioned that two feminine members of the EPP had been killed. Nobody else died. A Joint Job Drive agent sustained minor accidents.

Human Rights Watch reviewed public statements by authorities on the case and publicly obtainable proof. In response to a request from the entity, the Unbiased Forensic Skilled Group (IFEG) of the Worldwide Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims (IRCT), drew up an opinion on some components of the investigation.

Human Rights Watch detailed that it discovered severe irregularities within the investigation of the deaths from the start, and talked about some actions of the authorities:

– “They rushed to bury the victims with out performing an post-mortem”

– “They burned the garments of the victims”,

– “They keep, based mostly on an unreliable forensic examination, that one of many 11-year-old ladies fired a gun”

– “They made a dedication on the capturing distance that can not be substantiated by forensic proof.”

– “A consultant of the subsequent of kin was prohibited from being current at a forensic examination of the stays and was denied entry to the investigation.”

As concluded by Onder Ozkalipci and Karen Kelly, two worldwide forensic specialists who’re a part of IFEG, the destruction of women’ clothes “represents the destruction of essential proof that violates probably the most primary and elementary ideas of forensics and felony investigation, ”mentioned HRW.

The group remarked that “the worldwide requirements that require the efficient investigation of all instances of deaths brought on by State forces require the preservation of this proof.”

Vivanco recalled that the Paraguayan forensic knowledgeable who examined the our bodies on the scene, Cristian Ferreira, informed the media that the ladies They had been shot from the entrance after which from the again and from the aspect, and that the our bodies had been left face down on the bottom.



Related Articles